If you're paranoid that the mild-mannered Muslim family down the street are secret terrorists, or that a Department of State aide with a foreign-sounding name is a deep-cover mole for the Muslim Brotherhood, then "islamophobe" might be an appropriate label to affix to you.
On the other hand, if you're genuinely worried about the spread of a culture that advocates lynching an 11-year-old girl because she had a burnt piece of paper in her bag that may or may not have been from a Qur'an, I'd say you're a rational human being who is rightfully afraid of a truly horrible thing.
"This girl is guilty. If the state overrides the court, then God will get a person to do the job," said Raheem.
If that kind of thought is viewed as a positive thing in your religion, consider me militantly intolerant of your beliefs.
I recently posted about the infuriating case of Alexander Aan, an Indonesian atheist who was thrown in prison and slapped with a $10,000 fine for blasphemous postings on Facebook. He's also received numerous death threats, and some fundamentalist Muslims are calling for him to be executed.
Now there's a petition out on the White House's We the People service to pressure Obama to take a stand and call out Indonesia on this injustice. If it gets 25,000 signatures, it will end up on his desk in the Oval Office. It's currently at about 3100, so there's a long way to go. Go. Sign. It.
In my opinion, any person who values freedom of expression, be they atheist or not, should be signing this.
As I said in my post on Skeptic Freethought about this issue: If you are an atheist and have ever expressed your views online, you would be a criminal in Indonesia. Atheism should not be a crime anywhere.
I'm hopefully getting back in the swing of this blogging thing again. This time I'm shooting for making mid-month rehashes of stories from around the internet a regular feature. Let's do this.
Is that an octopus on your genitals, or are you just ha... wait, what?
So, in case any of you haven't seen it yet, this image started going viral yesterday:
Photo credit: Joan Gonzalvo
Best comment I've seen so far: "That's gotta suck."
Mid-month absurdity: Divine revelation is now probable cause?
Last year, a self-proclaimed psychic told the Sheriff's Office of Liberty County, Texas, that a local couple had 25 to 30 dismembered children buried on their property. This prompted a raid on their home by deputies and put the couple in the media spotlight internationally (largely because the Sheriff's Office tipped off the media before executing the search warrant).
As it turns out, the couple weren't really serial killers and didn't even have one dismembered child buried in their yard, let alone 25 to 30 of them. Now they're (rightfully) suing the Liberty County Sheriff's Office for defaming them and ransacking their home on the word of a charlatan.
The charlatan in question had this to say for herself:
“They up front asked me how I got the information, and I am a reverend. I am a prophet and I get my information from Jesus and the angels, and I told them that I had 32 angels with me and they were giving me the information and then it went from there,” she said.
Jesus and 32 angels told her about it? Must be legit.
Atheism gets you 2 1/2 years in prison in Indonesia
I hope by now that all of you who love freedom have heard of what's happening to Alexander Aan of Indonesia. If not, go read up on it.
He's going to prison and will spend the next 2 and a half years locked up with dangerous criminals for asserting God's non-existence on an atheist group page on Facebook. He also has to pay a fine of roughly $10,600 US.
“These atheists should be beheaded, that’s what they deserve,” wrote a man who identified himself as Putra Tama, a Muslim from neighboring Jambi province.
The Islamic Society Forum (FUI), an umbrella group for several hard-line groups, said that a five-year jail term for Aan would not suffice.
“He deserves the death penalty, even if he decides to repent. What he has done cannot be tolerated,” said Muhammad al-Khaththath, FUI’s secretary-general.
“It is important to prevent this group from spreading atheism in this country,” he added.
That doesn't bode well for him; how many Islamic extremists are going to be sharing a cell block with him? It's morbid, but I wouldn't be surprised some righteous zealot sticks him with a shiv in the name of God.
At any rate, it isn't even legal to be an atheist in Indonesia. You can choose from a laundry list of state-approved religions, but "none of the above" isn't an option.
Note to self: don't go to Indonesia.
If you're interested, the Atheist Alliance International is collecting donations for a legal fund to help Aan fight this ridiculous conviction. If you want to contribute to that specific fund, make sure you tick the appropriate box before donating.
Indonesia doesn't exactly have the world's most permissive religious freedom laws, but surely nothing like that would happen in a bastion of liberty like a Western nation, right?
Yeah. Wrong.
John Richards, an elderly man living in Boston (a small town on the eastern coast of England), has a sign hanging in his window proclaiming religion as fairy tales for adults.
I may have linked to her old blog as recommended reading last year, but Chana Messinger has a new blog that she updates frequently, writing about all sorts of interesting topics like feminism, skepticism, and occasionally food. Go check it out.
I've been more of an observer than a contributor these past several weeks. My take on a few recent items in the news and blogosphere:
The Catholic League wants to help us this Christmas!
The good folks over at the Catholic League know what a struggle it is for we atheists to keep up the charade day after day. Deep down, we all want to admit to the world that we're really Christians, imprisoned by peer pressure that keeps us from weeping tears of joy over Baby Jesus every time we see a crèche.
Well, despair no more, my fellow atheists! This season, let's all get adopted by a good Catholic who can show us the light! I know it's what all of us have secretly wanted all our lives.
For those of you who really aren't "closeted Christians" and are still tired of people saying that you "believe in nothing, stand for nothing and are good for nothing", Ellen over at Skeptic Freethought has a much better idea: tell those well-meaning Christians to adopt a puppy!
Stop oppressing Maldivian Muslims by telling them that flogging women is wrong!
“This is a very serious problem. You can’t say flogging is a form of violence against women,” he said.
Nasheed explained that Pillay’s remarks were tantamount to proclaiming in the Indian parliament that “worshiping cows is so uncivilised.”
Tearing a woman's flesh from her bones with a whip really is the same thing as giving livestock undue reverence. Why can't we just respect people's beliefs?
Atheists don't shelter their children from religion?
Apparently, scientists who don't believe in God still have a tendency to send their children to church. While sometimes it's to satisfy the religious sensibilities of a believing spouse, that's not always the case - some atheist parents actually want their kids to be exposed to religion so they can evaluate it for themselves!
One of the most interesting findings, according to Ecklund, was that some atheist scientists want to expose their children to religion due to scientific reasoning.
"We thought that these individuals might be less inclined to introduce their children to religious traditions, but we found the exact opposite to be true," Ecklund said. "They want their children to have choices, and it is more consistent with their science identity to expose their children to all sources of knowledge."
Freethinkers supporting free thought? Who'd have expected that?
For the record: my future kids will find the Bible and Qur'an on the same shelf as Greek and Norse mythology, though I might refrain from reading them certain stories from the first two until they're old enough not to be traumatized by the extreme violence.
Can we trade the current Newt for the 2006 edition?
A surprising revelation was tweeted this week, courtesy of Phil Plait: Newt Gingrich used to be pro-science! Here's an excerpt of an interview from 2006 (emphasis and Q/A notations mine):
Q: Do you view evolution as "just a theory" or as the best explanation for how we came to be?A: Evolution certainly seems to express the closest understanding we can now have. But it's changing too. The current tree of life is not anything like a 19th-century Darwinian tree. We're learning a lot about how systems evolve and don't evolve. Cockroaches became successful several hundred million years ago and just stopped evolving.
Q: Where do you come down on teaching intelligent design in schools? Do you think the ruling in the Dover, Pennsylvania, case was appropriate?A: I believe evolution should be taught as science, and intelligent design should be taught as philosophy. Francis Collins's new book, The Language of God, is a fine statement that combines a belief in God with a belief in evolution. I do not know enough about the Dover case to critique the judge's decision, but I am generally cautious about unelected judges establishing community standards—that is the duty of elected officials.
Don't we all wish that GOP candidates could get away with that kind of talk today? Unfortunately for us, they know their base and know how to pander to it. If you don't proclaim evolution to be just a silly "theory" (in the vernacular sense, not the scientific sense), you just aren't electable.
I was recently alerted to this video's existence via a Facebook post by a conservative Christian associate of mine. It was created by CitizenLink, a Focus on the Family affiliate.
It's more of the same message we often see from social conservative "pro-family" organizations: that "parents" (read: heterosexual Christian parents) should be "concerned" (read: alarmed) about "homosexual indoctrination" (read: teaching kids that they shouldn't regard gay people as horrible, immoral monsters) in schools.
For what it's worth, I know that there are at least a handful of gay activists out there who do have a disdain for heterosexuals and do want special treatment for their orientation. With a little bit of dressing up, this fringe element serves as a handy strawman for anti-gay activists to reference in videos like this. Don't be fooled. The vast majority of homosexuals just want to be who they are without being treated like freaks. That's your real "gay agenda".
If you don't want to sit through the whole thing, skip to 6:48 for the part that really made my blood boil.
". . . it is clear that these kids are struggling."
Around the 7-minute mark the show's host plays a clip from a "tolerance" video promoted by a gay advocacy group. In the clip we see teenagers giving their candid perceptions of their own gender identities, followed by the host and her guest reacting with thinly veiled disgust. They no doubt picked this clip thinking that it represents the worst of the gay indoctrination that students face, and I personally saw nothing wrong with what that clip depicted. What exactly is wrong with boys not acting masculine? Girls admitting that they're not 100% feminine? More importantly, what evidence is there that these kids are "struggling" any more than any other teenager struggles with life?
Of course, that's a rhetorical question. I know that the people who are alarmed by the blurring of boundaries between gendered behaviors feel that way because it demolishes two immutable categories that they've constructed in their minds. "Men and women are fundamentally different, even without counting the genitals and physiological differences, and should always behave as such, and you'll never convince me otherwise!" says my social conservative strawman.
What's really damaging is the idea that there can't be middle ground in gender issues, that you're either a manly man, a womanly woman, a girly gay boy, or a butch lesbian. No room for bisexuals, or even heterosexuals who exhibit personality traits of both genders, exists in this mindset (let alone trans- or intersexuals!).
An admonition for conservatives who aren't anti-gay
I understand that there are plenty of economic conservatives out there who don't have a problem with anyone's sexual orientation or gender identity so long as they're productive citizens. I understand your sentiment that gay advocacy is intruding on public school curriculum with programs like those described in the video, and likewise that lawsuits for the same cause are frivolous and that government intervention on it is excessive. I don't completely agree with that sentiment, but I understand where it comes from.
What secular conservatives should understand is that much of the left-wing sentiment backing this type of aggressive advocacy was forged by the backlash from social conservatives against those homosexuals who have "come out" over the past few decades. Gay rights activists built up this momentum while fighting a culture war for their right to exist in society. Tell the religious zealots who have hijacked the Republican Party to stop fighting culture wars and focus on the economy, and you won't have to listen to this senseless debate any longer.
If this article is accurate, it appears that Ghana's government is taking notes from the Inquisition, colonial-era witch hunts, and fascism:
Ghana’s Western Region Minister, Paul Evans Aidoo MP has ordered the immediate arrest of all homosexuals in the country’s west.
Aidooo has tasked Ghana’s Bureau of National Investigations and security forces to round up the country’s gay population and has called on landlords and tenants to inform on people they suspect of being homosexuals.
Never mind everything that's wrong with arresting adults for consensual relations with other adults; encouraging citizens to rat each other out like this will create an environment of fear among the people there. Will a quarrel with a neighbor lead him to accuse you of homosexuality? Should you accuse him first out of self-preservation?
They won't notice it coming until the undesirables are all gone and they have no one left to despise but each other.
While looking for other articles on this matter (I tend to be skeptical of stories that can only be traced back to a single news source), I stumbled across this opinion piece:
Ghanaians are first and foremost Afrikan people and must be proud and respect their Afrikan culture and value systems AND MUST NOT allow themselves to be hoodwinked into accepting something that is alien to their culture and value systems.
I've seen this kind of rhetoric before, and not just from the Christian and Muslim hardliners. Even African-American atheists have promoted this view that tolerance of homosexuality is an affront to the "Afrikan" way of life.
Sorry, but human rights aren't culturally relative. Celebrate your heritage all you like, but your right to swing your fist ends at the tip of another person's nose.
It turns my stomach to imagine myself half-buried in a pit, feeling the impacts shatter my bones and teeth and rupture blood vessels. It's even more revolting to imagine myself in the mob surrounding the victim, my peers coercing me to pick up a stone and throw it at the shrouded, bleeding figure in the pit.
It's likely the oldest form of execution employed by our species, and though it predates Islam by eons its continued use today seems to be most prevalent in theocratic Islamic countries. I hate to jump to conclusions about blaming religion for human evils that could exist independent of such beliefs, but there's really no way around it in this case: fundamentalist Islam is the most prominent force keeping stoning alive today. The penalty of death by stoning is implemented not for only the most heinous crimes, but for mere violations of social norms. Adultery, fornication, homosexuality, being a rape victim, and refusing to go along with an arranged marriage are all offenses punishable with death by stoning in some parts of the Islamic world.
What sickens me the most about this brutality is that I'm practically helpless to stop it. What are we to do, invade every country in which stoning still occurs? That won't fix it. Such a conflict could go on forever. Is it too much to hope for that our species could cast this horror aside once and for all? Or is it only realistic to expect that it will endure in some communities on and on into the future?
For now, we can at least put strong diplomatic pressure on countries like Iran whose governments do have the power to curb the practice. It's worked before, or at least is working so far for one case. Apart from foolhardy armed intervention, it's all we can really do.
My state is once again making headlines: yesterday the Ohio House of Representatives approved the so-called "Heartbeat Bill" (HB 125), which would ban all abortions in the state after the first detectable fetal heartbeat (normally 6-7 weeks along, often before a woman knows that she's pregnant), except in cases where the life of the pregnant woman is in danger. This naturally has provoked the "pro-choice" camp into a defensive frenzy, stepping up the campaign to defeat the bill in the Senate.
In my opinion, the debate over abortion and the restriction thereof is the most legitimate controversy we have in our society. It's an ethical dilemma at the collision point between two rights: that of human beings not to be unlawfully deprived of life, and that of human beings to retain sovereignty over their own bodies. It's an ugly debate convoluted by tough questions and mired by personal insults thrown from both sides, and it needs to be talked about in a rational manner.
Before discussing further, I want to give a curt admonition to each of the opposing factions:
Pro-lifers: Stop disingenuously talking about an embryo with a circulatory system as if it's biologically equivalent to a live toddler. It's not.
Pro-choicers: Stop disingenuously saying that this bill "threatens women's lives" when it makes a clear exception for medical necessity. That alarmist catchphrase should be saved for cases when it truly applies; the issue in contention here is women's privacy and control over their own bodies.
*** EDIT: As Ginx correctly points out, the bill's passage could indirectly threaten Ohio women's lives by making it more likely for them to seek out potentially risky and unsanitary "back alley" abortions; if the embryo they're carrying has a pulse, then no Ohio doctor could legally perform the procedure. What the bill directly threatens, however, is their rights regarding their bodies. ***
Seriously, Beijing? If the past two millennia have taught non-Christians anything, it's that arresting Christians for openly celebrating their beliefs is really not an effective way to convince them that their religion is false. It has the certain consequence of strengthening their faith and earning them sympathy from other people who are also sick of your oppressive government. Christianity is a religion that is rejuvenated by martyrdom and thrives upon keeping the faith in the face of persecution; arresting 20 churchgoers on Easter Sunday is like throwing a bucket of gasoline on a fire you're trying to extinguish.
Take note, American Jesus-worshipers who whine about secularism: this is what persecution looks like. It's not just teaching science which contradicts your creation myths; it's not telling you we don't want our money or court houses dedicated to your God; it's not letting you to pray on your own time instead of having a federal holiday designated for doing so. It's arresting you just for going to church on the pagan holiday co-opted to celebrate the fabled resurrection of your Savior.